The Lotus Takes a Step Back to Go Forward
A few weeks ago, I wrote about bringing my ’74 Lotus Europa Twin Cam special back from warehouse storage. The drive home was a bit of an adventure, as the car’s fuel filter kept clogging up and strangling the gas flow into the Strombergs. This required a parking lot intervention to disconnect the filter and blow it out, which was accompanied by the quintessential gas-in-the-armpit experience that distinguishes us true wrenches from the rest of you posers.
I needed to bring the Lotus home because, in addition to missing it during its September-to-May warehouse sojourn while I sorted out a registration issue (a story I keep teasing you with but I promise I will tell it), I wanted to try to set the car’s suspension right.
Europas are very low cars, only 42 inches high at the roof, and their snowplow-low nose ran them into trouble with U.S. headlight height regulations. For this reason, unlike earlier S1 and S2 Europas, the Federal-spec Twin Cam cars have a nose that’s raised a bit. It’s not jacked up that much, maybe an inch and a half or two, but the rest of the car is so low that it’s noticeable. People joke that it makes the Twin Cam look like a boat on plane.
When I bought the Europa in 2013, it had been sitting for 30 years. It was very original, but it needed everything, including an engine rebuild. Figuring out how to do that in a cost-effective manner took me six years. Job loss and career change put a cap on my spending, so the car in no way got “restored.” When I finally finished rebuilding the engine and installed it in the spring of 2019, I did the minimum necessary to get the car running and driving. In other words, new brakes, yes, new suspension, no, body-off repaint and powder-coated frame, hell no. So although I was thrilled to finally be driving the Europa, experiencing the car’s legendary handling was deferred, as the shocks were at that point 45 years old and barely functional.
In the car’s second round of work that winter, I wanted to address both the old tired suspension as well as the raised nose. The Europa’s suspension uses double wishbones in the front with coil-overs on both the front and rear. It’s a 1600-pound vehicle, so the springs are tiny—2.25 inches in diameter in the front, and 1.9 inches in the back. The trick thing to do is buy adjustable Spax shocks—that’s “adjustable” in both ride height as well as firmness—and shorter, stiffer springs. However, doing so would’ve set me back over twelve hundred bucks, and I couldn’t justify spending that.
So I did what I often do—I tried to find a less expensive path. It was easy to look up the free lengths and spring rates of both the stock springs and the commonly-used lowering springs on Europa user forums. The stock front springs have 14-inch free length with a 100-pound spring rate. The consensus on front lowering springs for street use was 10-inch 125-pound. I found some for just $85 for the pair brand new. I kept the rear springs stock. Then I found an old set of used adjustable Spax shocks with the springs still on them on eBay, something someone had likely installed on their Europa S2 in the 1980s. The seller knew nothing about their history, but they were cheap; I think I paid $200 plus shipping. I negotiated with the seller that, as long as the shocks weren’t seized or blown, and the firmness adjustment worked, I’d be happy. They weren’t, they did, and I was.
Since the used shocks came with springs on them that were likely off a Europa S2 (which aren’t the same as the ones on a Twin Cam), the first thing I had to do was get them off. I discovered that none of the four spring compressors I owned would work—the springs were either too narrow in diameter or the coils too close together, or both. I bought and returned an ATV spring compressor on Amazon that wouldn’t fit, then read on the Europa forum that people make their own using either hooks and turnbuckles or plates and threaded rods. I know, it seems impossibly hokey from the photos, but I asked a friend who works at one of the vintage Lotus parts houses in this country, and he says that this is how they do it. The parts for lowering the nose all went in, along with a general steering rebuild (new ball joints and trunions) between December 2019 and spring of 2020.
There were a few things I didn’t count on. One was that lowering the nose required shortening the sway bar links. Unlike most cars where the middle of the sway bars bolt to the frame and the ends are attached to the lower control arms with links, the ends of the Europa’s sway bars attach directly to the bottoms of the shocks, and the links hang down from the upper wishbone’s attachment point. It’s weird. One of these links was already broken, so I cut them both, threaded them with a die, and installed an adjustable turnbuckle that bolted onto a clamp meant for attaching phones and cameras to cycle handlebars. It worked fine.
The resulting car looked great with the lowered nose, but from the get-go, I didn’t like the effect the springs and shocks had on the car’s ride. No matter how I adjusted the shocks on the soft-firm spectrum, it seemed that the car, particularly the nose, would bottom out on anything other than glass-smooth pavement.
Over the next few years, I discovered other undesirable side effects of my modifications. Lowering any vintage car with non-camber-correcting suspension by simply installing shorter springs will usually increase negative camber (push the bottoms of the wheels outward), and just looking at the Lotus’ front wheels, I could see that that had happened in spades. Adjustable front wishbones are available for the Europa, but they’re not cheap, and adjustment requires popping the ball joint out of its taper and screwing its other attachment point in or out. Again, I cheaped out by simply elongating the bolt holes at the outer ends of the wishbones. I’m not the first one to have done this. It’s as old a trick as cutting coils.
The next booge-on-top-of-kluge was that, while driving at highway speeds, I became obsessed with the fact that the car’s lane-changing seemed to occur as two steps, with the nose moving first, then followed by the tail. I posed the question to the Europa forum, and the consensus was to have a professional alignment done. I didn’t want to do that, because, you know, I’m cheap and all, but also because the rear toe-in is adjusted by placing shims (washers, really) between the rear trailing arms and the frame. In other words, it’s not something your all-makes-all-models $125 alignment shop is going to do. It needs to be done by a Lotus specialty shop, or by you at home followed by repeated trips to the alignment shop to see if you got it right. As I’ve written about, I’ve been doing my own alignments for years, and was convinced that I’d gotten the rear toe-in close enough that it couldn’t be the cause. I blamed the problem on mismatched springs. That is, I’d replaced the front springs with shorter stiffer ones, but was still running on the original rear springs. So I bought rear lowering springs of the same length and stiffness specs that are used in the pricey lowering packages. As happened with the front wheels, they had the effect of cambering the bottoms of the rear wheels out, so down that rabbit hole I went and built adjustable rear links, dialing in the camber with both an analog bubble level and a digital inclinometer.
The total effect of all of this was, in retrospect, predictable—I’d taken a car that was fairly comfortable to drive, and turned it into an oxcart that could barely clear a pack of cigarettes. I read more on the Europa forum, and came to the conclusion that, because the eBay-purchased used adjustable Spax shocks were off a Europa S2 with stock springs, they were never meant to be used with lowering springs. When I bought them, I simply didn’t understand that there was a distinction between adjustable damping, which they had, and adjustable perch height, which they didn’t. Using shorter springs on shocks that weren’t meant for them was likely what was making things bottom out. I wanted to return the car to the way that it was, but the original shocks were so soft as to be indistinguishable from being blown, so I’d thrown them away.
Then it occurred to me: I didn’t have the original shocks, but I did have the original springs. I could install them on the used Spax adjustable shocks that were currently on the car. There was nothing obviously wrong with those. That would put the car back to its original height. And once that was done, I could undo all the questionable camber changes, as they’d no longer be necessary.
Put another way, I felt like an idiot having made the car less comfortable and less drivable with my budget-conscious suspension mods, so given the choice between feeling like even more of an idiot spending probably close to two grand for a vetted adjustable suspension and wishbone package to do it right, or feeling like even more of an idiot taking the time and effort to return it to close to the way it was before I started to futz with it, when the whole situation and both ways out of it made me feel like more of an idiot anyway, I opted for the zero-cost path. Hey, if you’re going to feel like more of an idiot, at least it should cost you nothing, right?
So, as soon as the Lotus came home from the Monson warehouse, I had at it.
The rear shocks and springs came out first, as they’re just held on by through-bolts at the top and bottom. I unearthed my cobbled-together spring compressor from the back of the garage. Off the short springs came, on the original springs went. The bottom attachment bolt for the shocks goes through the adjustable rear links, so off those came, replaced by their original fixed grandfathers.
The front was quite a bit more involved, as the coil-overs sit between the halves of both the upper and lower wishbones, and the upper attachment point is held in place by a long bolt that has to be knocked backwards and through an access hole in the fiberglass body of the car (really). I did have a nice surprise, though, which was that the coil spacing of the aftermarket front lowering springs was wide enough that I could use a conventional plate-style spring compressor as long as I secured the assembly with a ratchet strap to keep the little spring from popping out of the plates.
While I was doing this, I noticed something new. Another reason the front lowering springs being removed fit in my standard compressor was that they’re wound with the spiral going upward in the counter-clockwise direction. I realized that every spring I’ve ever installed is wound that way… except the stock ones on the Lotus, which are wound in the opposite direction. This matters because if you look on any standard plate-style compressor, you’ll see that the plates are shaped to accept that orientation, with the right edge of the plate tipped higher than the left edge. It wouldn’t have made a difference with regard to removing and installing the original springs—the coil spacing is still so small that no plate-style compressor will fit between them—but it was another item to add to my “weird things about the Lotus” list.
Then I had a surprise with the sway bar links. That is, when I shortened them and made them adjustable, I didn’t design them (if you call what I did “design”) to go back to the way they were, so I now I needed to lengthen them. I cobbled something together with cut-off pieces of a shelving bracket.
But it’s all back together.
And?
Initially, there was thunking and clunking, but it traced back to my kludge solution for extending the sway bar links. Once I temporarily removed those, the Europa’s ride was much better. Although I’d rather that the nose was still hunkered down, the car is no longer bone-jarring to drive. Undoing my budget suspension modifications was the right thing to do, and it cost me nothing but time. Sometimes you really do need to take a step back in order to go forward.
But if anyone makes a boat-on-plane joke, I’m going to find their boat and steal their drain plugs.
***
Rob’s latest book, The Best Of The Hack Mechanic™: 35 years of hacks, kluges, and assorted automotive mayhem is available on Amazon here. His other seven books are available here on Amazon, or you can order personally-inscribed copies from Rob’s website, www.robsiegel.com.
Check out the Hagerty Media homepage so you don’t miss a single story, or better yet, bookmark it. To get our best stories delivered right to your inbox, subscribe to our newsletters.
Rob, should we assume that a pair of OEM Euro-spec Europa Twin Cam springs are not available at any of the suppliers? Otherwise, it seems like that would be the way to go, right? Keep it simple.
I have learned through the years with oddball cars that it’s usually cheapest to buy the right part first rather than spend more time and money cobbling together solutions that will ultimately need to be replaced by the right part anyway.
What kind of “The Hack Mechanic” column would that make?
“I sourced and bought the correct part. It fit and worked perfectly. Stay tuned next month for more!”
“There’s never enough time (money) to do it right, but always enough to do it over”.
I always thought the Europa was an interesting vehicle with boat like styling. This article reminded me of that.
Don’t worry I’m my own fault most of the time as well!
I regret I never bought a new Lotus Europa during a dealer visit, but at the time it just wasn’t practical. After a few “suspension changes” on cars I had in my younger years, I learned the factory stuff is surprisingly “all around” good for most driving. That is when I stayed away from “Ricky Racer” suspension modes. Years later I did a 1969 Oldsmobile Vista Cruiser wagon. BIG sums it up. I left the springs stock, Installed new good shocks, a bigger GTO front sway bar, and the boxed rear axle trailing arms with sway bar off a SS Chevelle. I also put installed 15″ Hurst Olds rims with HUGE soft tires. Folks were amazed how well it rode and the amount of lateral G force it could develop in a tight high speed turn. I installed a built 455 Olds engine and the car was one of the nicest all around cars I’ve ever owned and could haul parts and pull a car trailer with ease and in comfort.
Greetings Rob. Noticing your wall decoration in the garage brought to mind that if you only had access to the Krell intellect enhancer you would automatically know that this outcome would happen and thereby avoid all that work and rework. Of course you would have to be careful of the monsters from the id. Also, if Robby was available, you could ask him to run you off the proper parts to cure your issue with Lolita. Just a thought. Anyway, thanks for the interesting story.
I drove an S2 for over 50 years. Correct rear toe is crucial to handling at highway speeds. These cars like soft suspension. Both my front and rear shocks were set two clicks off full soft. Maybe using the S2 springs would have been an alternative.
I empathise soooooooooo much. But back to stock is almost always the solution to mods gone wrong.
Not sure which I appreciate the most, your story or your feedback from a highly informed community. So much fun to read and learn from!!
If the car was mine I would do one or two things one leave the car stock, two sell the car and call the car a pain in the butt to keep if you can’t enjoy it.
I just did a bunch of work on a europa. It was the worst engineered car I had ever worked on. Why anyone would waste their time on such a pile is beyond me.
From the moment I bought my first car, a ’92 Jetta at 18 years old, my philosophy has been that if you’re going to mess with something on a vehicle, whenever possible wait until you have the time, money, and knowledge to do it right. That’s why I drove it for 5 years with stock steel wheels and springs, albeit with fresh Boge shocks and decent Dunlop rubber.
My ’99 Miata has similarly only had the shocks off it once in the past 13 years I’ve owned it, whereupon I put a middle-of-road, tried-and-true spring, shock and sway bar setup on it that went on smoothly and has served me well on road and track. It was also well worth my while to send an hour’s labour to get the alignment set to performance specs. It’s starting to feel a little rough now. I’m not sure whether that’s due to shocks, roads, or me aging, so I might be going for another upgrade.
Whether I spent $1,000 or $2,000 on the suspension over a decade ago makes no difference to my bank account today, but the trouble-free, pleasant experience is something I enjoyed whenever I’ve driven the car.
Rob if you ever need a spring that you can’t find anywhere there’s a company not far from you that will wind anything you want at reasonable cost. Hardware Products in Chelsea once wound two springs to my specifications and I could not have been happier with them.