1957 MGA High-School Cool: Hair-Raising Adventures in My Very First Car

Gary Witzenburg

It was dark, with little traffic on my way home from a date when I dozed, briefly, at the wheel. I opened my eyes to see the two-lane road sweeping right and the double-yellow centerline flowing left-to-right under my MGA’s dim headlight beams. I jammed on the brakes, steered right and felt the car’s skinny rear tires lose grip as its back end headed left. Whoa!

I quickly steered back left to catch the slide, and the rear end snapped back right. Damn! This, I later learned, was what racers call a “tank slapper” as the car’s tail whipped one way, then the other. Then I realized that I was still hard on the brakes, and backing off that pressure enabled me to regain control. Whew—a near-disastrous lesson in car control at the tender age of 16!

I had just recently acquired my driver’s license yet was hardly inexperienced. My expert-driver father had let me steer his car as a little kid sitting on his lap and had taught and trained me in safe driving most of my life. Then, from ages 14 to 16, I survived two years on a motor scooter as my all-season daily driver, and I learned a life-saving lot about defensive driving, operating in traffic, and dealing with slippery conditions as the scooter’s brake cables often froze and left me essentially brakeless in Cleveland’s nasty winter weather.

At age 15, with no legal license, I had stolen my mom’s ’57 Ford convertible nearly every Friday night, when my folks were away in a bowling league, and I had somehow gotten away with driving that cool car all over the place in all kinds of conditions without incident. I never got caught, and my folks never knew, since they would have punished me severely for that foolishly risky habit. So, when my car-guy dad surprised me with a well-used 1957 MGA roadster for Christmas three weeks before my 16th birthday, I could not have been more thrilled.

1957 MG MGA side profile rear three quarter
Gary Witzenburg

To be honest, my very first car was not actually that MGA. Instead, my dad had bought a goofy Lloyd 600, a tiny 23-hp German microcar, at a local import dealership, and it was to be my Christmas and 16th birthday present. But very thankfully, I never saw that little POS. The auto gods were smiling down on me the day he picked it up, because it clanked to a smoky halt just a few feet out of the lot. More than a little pissed, he then harassed the dealer into a friendly price on the MGA and stored it at a friend’s house awaiting the big Christmas morning presentation.

But my introduction to that red, wire-wheeled beauty was traumatic. Before hitting the sack on Christmas Eve, I noticed our garage full of white smoke. I rolled up the door to see the MGA with its hood up, my mom standing in shock, and my father frantically searching for the battery. We finally found two separate six-volt batteries behind the seats, but the electrical system was well cooked by the time we got them unhooked. “Merry Christmas,” grimaced my frustrated dad.

Once repaired and functional (I’d love to have seen my 6’ 4” dad’s second angry confrontation with that dealer), that MGA could not have been a much cooler set of high-school wheels. Thanks to years of hard work and Dad’s good job, we were comfortably middle class but far from wealthy. Some of my classmates were, but some had no wheels at all; a couple drove restored Ford Model As (pretty cool), but no one else had a sexy “poor man’s Jaguar” British roadster.

It was a little rusty (which didn’t show much thanks to its red paint); its first-gear’s synchro was history so was hard to engage without grinding a bit; its infamous Lucas electrics went missing in the rain from time to time—which required removing and hand-drying its distributor cap and a few other parts; and its cable-operated door latches were weak. But all that seemed well worth the trouble to a good-student, bad-athlete, car-loving, marginally likeable 16-year-old.

I did almost lose girlfriend Betsy out the passenger door when it flew open while I spun a quick U-turn after picking her up. Good thing she grabbed the windshield pillar to avoid meeting the street! She eventually forgave me, and the MGA, and enjoyed riding in it. Except when I wouldn’t stop to erect its top after it started raining. That was a clumsy, 15–20-minute operation, so I figured we’d get wetter while stopped to put it up than we would just driving in the rain. And the faster I drove, the more the rain swept over the windshield, and our heads.

Gary-Witzenburg-and-Betsy-Ellis-1960-edited
The author and his girlfriend-at-the-time, Betsy Ellis, circa 1960.Gary Witzenburg

I also vividly remember some snow-related adventures in that car. On the very first night I had my license, I drove over to Betsy’s house and offered her a ride. After a serious conversation with her dad, he agreed to let her go with me despite a fairly heavy snowfall going on. Thinking back, had she been my daughter, I probably would have said, “No way.”

And even though I was already a fairly experienced driver when I got my license (much more than my dad knew…), he signed me up for driving lessons to get a break on insurance, which was pricey even then for teen drivers. It was snowing hard on the day of my second lesson, and the instructor climbed in and let me take him for a ride. Which I did … way out of town and back, in increasingly heavy snow. I was a ridiculously over-confident driver even then so gave him what must have been a hair-raising ride sliding around sideways on slippery roads. I thought he might be impressed by my car-control skill. But as I recall, he just sat there, probably terrified, and didn’t say anything at all.

That turned out to be my last lesson, so maybe the instructor refused to ride with me again and told his colleagues to avoid me as well. My dad never confirmed whether he got the insurance break after I failed to complete those lessons, but I’m guessing he probably didn’t.

Another snow-related incident started out as grins but ended scary. A friend and I were having fun driving around with both side window panels out and our door pockets full of snowballs. We were pitching them out at passing cars as we drove and managed to hit a few. Then one driver we hit came after us. I led him on a lively chase through snow-covered suburban back roads and alleys, but he hung right with us. When we finally drove into a blocked alley and had to stop, he and a bigger guy jumped out and caught us. They threatened to kick the crap out of us but just yelled, lectured us, and let us go. But not before tossing my car key into a snowbank. We scraped around in the snow for a while, found the key and headed home, one good scare wiser.

1957 MG MGA front three quarter
Gary Witzenburg

I wasn’t a good enough (self-taught) mechanic to mess with the MGA’s mechanicals, but I did (for some reason) take off easily removable parts under its hood and spray paint them different colors. And one important modification was installing aftermarket seatbelts, since the car had come without belts from the factory. My dad had optional ones in his company car, a 1960 Thunderbird, and trained me to habitually use them—a habit that likely saved my life years later in my first new car, a 1966 Triumph TR4A.

Did I have the belt installed, and was I using it, when I so nearly lost control on that dark night? I honestly don’t recall. But I do remember that the MGA’s floorboard was wood, and that belt probably would have ripped right through it in a violent flip, despite the large washers I used to secure its anchors. Further, the MGA’s windshield frame was flimsy, to say the least. So, belted in or not, that was one of many times in my life when the driving survival gods were smiling on me.

That old MGA was truly cool for school if a bit rusty, slow, and unreliable. After a year with it, I was lusting for something more powerful and threatening to trade it for an older Corvette. I even checked out a couple of not-so-cherry ’54 and ’55 Corvettes. Then my dad (bless his car-loving heart), on a business trip to Detroit, found a nice ’57 Corvette for sale by a couple who needed the money and talked them down to (as I recall) just $1500. It was a black base car with a white convertible top, a detachable hardtop, a 245-hp twin-4-barrel 283 V-8, and a two-speed Powerglide automatic. He brought it home, and we sold the MGA.

That Corvette was even cooler, much faster, and potentially more treacherous. I somehow survived my high-school senior year with it, but that’s a story for another time.

***

Check out the Hagerty Media homepage so you don’t miss a single story, or better yet, bookmark it. To get our best stories delivered right to your inbox, subscribe to our newsletters.

Click below for more about
Read next Up next: Review: 2023 Volvo XC40 Nails Fashion and Function

Comments

    An article of memories …. my 57 MGA was acquired when I was a freshman is college. It proved to just as described in your article, and I had some similar experiences. I was always fixing something and still remember the first time I pulled the engine to replace the clutch. Always had a towel handy incase it rained. Sold that car to buy my wife’s wedding ring 60 years ago!

    Good stories and as an owner of MGA’s for over 25 years, they are great little cars and with proper maintenance are just as reliable as anything else. Oh, and by the way, your ’57 MGA never had a synchro on first gear, thus the reason for “hard shifting into first without grinding” especially if still moving.
    Straight cut sliding gear on all of them.

    I had a ‘59 MG A in High School, you almost lost Betsy on a tight turn, I almost lost a young lady named Janice during a similar turn. The car was a mechanical/electrical nightmare, but on a nice (dry) day with the top down, it was a real joy to drive (until something fell off). Owning that car taught me more about auto repair than any shop class could have ever done. I’ve had some pretty interesting cars since then, but every time I see an “A” at a car show, the memories come flooding back (or maybe that’s just the roof, side curtains and floor doing the flooding). Fun car.

    I had a 57 MGA exactly like the author’s. It was 1966 and I was 16 years old. Paid $650 from my wages working at a grocery store. Yes, it was the coolest car at my high school. Only owned it 6 months before my brother totaled it is a serious accident. Luckily, he survived and I am still waiting for him to reimburse me. 🙂

    Much cooler than my first car, purchased after my college freshman year: a black 1959 Renault 4CV with all of 28 hp. Became my daily driver for 14 years and my girlfriend married me in spite of it. Still have wife and 4CV, both in great shape!

    Got my ’57 when I turned 16 – $600 of hard earned money – got a 2nd one (’59) – the 2nd was the spare when one was not running – wonderful cars and I miss them greatly – now have a ’73 E type roadster – lot more difficult to maintain but turns heads. 🙂

    My ’58 came to me in several boxes in 1970. The original owner had undertaken a restoration project only to find that he had neither the skills nor the patience. I think I gave him $150 for the ‘car’. He had done all the cleaning, had the motor and trans refurbished and 90% of the paint work was complete. Had it on the road in six months and enjoyed it for several years until my ex-wife decided I needed a ‘real’ car. Not being able to justify having three cars I sold it and bought a Z car. She was not real pleased with that either. Should have kept the car and traded off the wife. Next wife went out and bought a TR6 for herself without my knowledge – my kinda girl!

    My older brother and I shared a 1957 Austin Healey 3000. The car looked great in white with a red interior. Among its very British quirks were an electric overdrive which had to be coaxed into action with the gentle tap of a hammer, a top which required a Ph.D. in engineering to erect, and side curtains which mandated the use of a raincoat even when we managed to erect the entire roofing structure. The girls loved it though, and I had the best summer of my life driving that car.

    I guess I just never grew up. I started with my first MGB when I was 16 (unknown to my mechanic father, so I had to hide it at my high school history teacher’s house—until she discovered the oil slick in her driveway). Fifty five years, three MGBs and two MGAs later, I’m still driving my 62 MGA MKII, and loving it! Still hooked!

    Great MGA article. At 70, I bought a first 61 MGA. I have no mechanical experience and am very fortunate my friend Tom installed a MGB 5 main bearing engine bored 0.30 over, a 3.9 MGB tubular differential for the highway, front MGB suspension with a sway bar, assisted power brake booster and a full syncro MGB transmission. I however was able to make the new wooden floor boards and am in the process of having the body painted black to compliment the tan interior and tan stayfast top. Thank you for posting the many articles I enjoy reading.

    Oh might like to know that the VIN of an MGA contains the color code. My 59 was painted red, but should’ve been a light blue.

    Living in Nova Scotia on the East Coast of Canada, we loving reading stories like this one about the 16 year old young man who’s father bought him his first car being a 1957 MGA. Our little BATANS British Car Club has about 600 British vehicles and 400 members of which a few also live in the USA and Europe. Thank you again and it is a pleasure being associated with Hagerty.

    In college back in 1974, I bought a 61 MGA. Painted gold with a brush, it had a big maple leaf impression just behind the seats. Over the next few years, we rebuilt the gearbox and engine, rewired it, stripped and repainted it, and did new seat covers and interior. It was a great first car, and I learned a ton about do it yourself car repairs. We sold it after my wife was too pregnant to get in and out of it. About 12 years ago, I purchased an 80 model MGB tourer as a date car. We still love to drive it around town! Nothing like the old MG’s!

    My first car was bought during my 1972 senior year in high school. It was a clapped-out, well-worn 1961 MGA bought for $300. It had a torn top and two bad 6-volt batteries wired to positive ground.
    I had minimal mechanical experience and few tools, especially metric.
    I kept that car running enough to get to work, but few girls wanted to ride in it.
    Being a wanna-be Jackie Stewart, I had several crashes in it and was always repairing dents and scrapes.
    One mishap was missing a curve and hitting a dirt bank. This broke the banjo string factory steering wheel. I bought an aftermarket wheel, but it would, not fit without a cast aluminum adaptor. I installed the adaptor, then screwed the new steering wheel to it, stripping out the aluminum threads over-tightening. The main voyage with the new steering wheel was with my dad, driving down our three-mile mountain road to town. We were traveling about 35mph when the first bolt vibrated out and fell in my lap. My dad looked over with a quizzical look. Shortly, the next two bolts fell out together, leaving me holding the now independent steering wheel. My dad and I had a brief two-second horrified eye-lock before the MGA sailed off the road and down a ravine. The were no injuries and minimal damage, but my dad never let me drive that car again. Moved on to a 72 Javelin.
    That MGA will always be my first love. It got me started on a long list of open roadsters that I’m still adding to today. My mechanical skills and tools have grown much since then. Maybe it’s time for another MGA.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Your daily pit stop for automotive news.

Sign up to receive our Daily Driver newsletter

Subject to Hagerty's Privacy Policy and Terms of Conditions

Thanks for signing up.